What numbers can we make?

Imagine we have four bags containing a large number of 1s, 4s, 7s and 10s. What numbers can we make?

Exploring and noticing Working systematically Conjecturing and generalising Visualising and representing Reasoning, convincing and proving
Being curious Being resourceful Being resilient Being collaborative

What Numbers Can We Make? printable sheet with Charlie and Alison's representations

What Numbers Can We Make? printable sheet without Charlie and Alison's representations

 

Imagine you had four bags containing a large number of 1s, 4s, 7s and 10s.
 

Image
Four bags, containing 1s, 4s, 7s and 10s.

You can choose numbers from the bags and add them to make different totals. You don't have to use numbers from every bag, and there will always be as many of each number as you need.

Choose some sets of $3$ numbers and add them together.

What is special about your answers?

Can you explain what you've noticed?



Charlie and Alison came up with some ways to represent what was happening.

Charlie's representation:

 

All multiples of three can be represented as:

Image
What numbers can we make?

The numbers in the bags can be represented as:

Image
What numbers can we make?

Similarly, numbers which are two more than a multiple of three can be represented as:

Image
What numbers can we make?

When I choose three numbers, I end up with a multiple of three $+3$ which will be a multiple of three.

Image
What numbers can we make?

 



Alison's representation:

 

Since all multiples of three can be written in the form $3n$, the numbers in the bags can be written in the form $3n+1$.

Similarly, numbers which are two more than a multiple of three can be written in the form $3n+2$.

As long as I remember I'm working with multiples of three, I could call these numbers $+0$, $+1$ and $+2$ numbers for short.

When I choose three numbers, I'm adding together three $+1$s, so I end up with a multiple of three $+3$ which will be a multiple of three.

 

 

What if you choose sets of $4$ numbers and add them together?

What if you choose sets of $5$ numbers, $6$ numbers, $7$ numbers...?

What totals do you think it would be possible to make if you choose $99$ numbers? Or 100 numbers?

Can you use Charlie's and Alison's representations to convince yourself?

Printable NRICH Roadshow resource. 

Next, you might like to work on What Numbers Can We Make Now? or Take Three From Five