Sixty-Seven Squared
Evaluate these powers of 67. What do you notice? Can you convince someone what the answer would be to (a million sixes followed by a 7) squared?
Problem
Evaluate the following:
$67^2$
$667^2$
$6667^2$
$66667^2$
What do you notice?
Can you convince someone what the answer would be to (a million sixes followed by a 7) 2 ?
Getting Started
Lots of sixes followed by a seven can be written as a sum of a series involving powers of 10.
Student Solutions
Markland from The John Roan School, Gareth; Euen and Alex from Madras College, Scotland; and Chin Siang from Tao Nan School, Singapore; all sent in good solutions .
Jack from The Ridings High School described the pattern:
I noticed that the number of 4s and 8s each increased by 1 for each extra 6 and that the last digit was always a 9. I then predicted that 666667 ² would equal 444444888889 and I was correct. Therefore according to this pattern: (1 million 6s followed by a 7) ² would be written 1000001 4s followed by 1000000 8s followed by a nine.
| 67 2 | = | 4489 |
| 667 2 | = | 444889 |
| 6667 2 | = | 44448889 |
| 66667 2 | = | 4444488889 |
Doing these four calculations by long multiplication shows how this pattern works. If $m$ is the number of sixes in the number that is squared, the pattern is:
( $m$ sixes followed by $7$)$^2 =$ ($(m+1)$ $4$'s followed by $m$ $8$'s followed by a $9$).
So
(one million sixes followed by a $7$)$^2 =$ (one million and one $4$'s followed by a million $8$'s followed by a $9$).
| 666 | ... | 666667 | |||
| 666 | ... | 666667 | |||
| 4666 | ... | 666669 | (x7) | ||
| 40000 | ... | 000020 | (x60) | ||
| 400000 | ... | 000200 | (x600) | ||
| . | |||||
| . | |||||
| . | |||||
| 40 | ... | 000020 | ... | 000000 | (x 6 x 10 m -1 ) |
| 400 | ... | 000200 | ... | 000000 | (x 6 x 10 m ) |
| 444 | ... | 444888 | ... | 888889 | Total |
To prove the result using the sums of series, evaluate
$$[6(1 + 10 + 10^2 + \dots + 10^m) + 1]^2$$
to get
$$\left[6\left(\frac{10^{m+1} - 1}{9}\right) + 1\right]^2$$
Multiplying out and simplifying this gives
$$\frac{1}{9}\left(4 \times 10^{2(m+1)} + 4 \times10^{m+1} + 1\right)$$
Using
$$\frac{10^{p+1}}{9} = 1 + 10 + \dots + 10^p + \frac{1}{9}$$
for $p = 2m+1$ and $p = m$, we get
$$4\left(1 + 10 + 10^2 + \dots + 10^{2m+1}\right) + 4\left(1 + 10 + 10^2 + \dots + 10^{m}\right) + 1$$
which is written $444\dots888\dots9$ that is as $(m+1)$ $4$'s followed by $m$ $8$'s followed by a 9.
Teachers' Resources
Why do this problem?
An excellent exercise in using geometric series with a fun way into the problem through experimenting with numbers and making conjectures.
Possible approach
Let the students experiment with the numbers until they spot patterns and make conjectures. If they don't see how to prove the general result you may have to ask the 'key question' and suggest using the sum of a geometric series.
Key questions
Can you write the number (k sixes followed by a 7) in terms of powers of 10 which will work for all k?
Possible extension
Try the problem Clickety Click and All the Sixes