# Implicitly

## Problem

$X(r)$ is defined implicitly by the quadratic relationship

$$

r^2X^2-rX-r+1=0

$$

Part 1: Which of the choices $r=1,-1,100$ give real values for $X(r)$?

Part 2: What is the range of values of $r$ for which $X(r)$ takes real values?

What happens when $r=0$?

Part 3: Sketch the overall shape of $X(r)$ against $r$ and find the maximum and minimum values of $X(r)$.

Note: You could numerically find a sensible conjecture for the minimum and maximum values of $X(r)$, but to prove this you will need to use calculus.

## Getting Started

Use the quadratic equation formula. When are the roots real?

Note that $X(r)$ is a 'multivalued' function with $2$ possible values of $X$ for each value of $r$.

## Student Solutions

Two of our best solvers, Alex from Stoke on Trent Sixth Form College and Patrick from Woodbridge School thought about this implicit equation.

$$r^2X^2-rX-r+1=0$$

Patrick looked at the first parts using the quadratic equation formula as follows:**Part 1**:

If $r=1$ then $X^2-X = 0$, so $X(X-1) = 0$ and $X = 0$ or $1$.

If $r = 100$ then $100^2X^2 - 100X - 100 + 1 = 0$ so $100^2X^2-100X-99 = 0$ so

$$

X = \frac{100\pm \sqrt{100 ²+4\times 100 ²\times 99}}{ 2\times 100^2}

$$

This is real as we neither divide by $0$ nor take a negative square root.**Part 2**:

If $r = 0$ then we find the equation gives $1=0$, so r cannot equal $0$.

Substituting $r^2$ for $a$, $-r$ for $b$ and $-(r-1)$ for $c$ in the usual quadratic equation formula we get

$$

X = \frac{r\pm\sqrt{r ²+4r ²(r-1)}}{2r^2}=\frac{1\pm\sqrt{1+4r-4}}{2r} = \frac{1\pm\sqrt{4r-3}}{2r}

$$

So this takes real values if and only if $4r - 3 \geq 0$.

Alex realised that the key feature of this problem was the discriminant of the quadratic equations in $X$, and looked at that object directly:

The discriminant determines whether a quadratic has real roots, therefore $X(r)$ will have real values if and only if the discriminant $D$ of the quadratic is zero or positive.

$$

\begin{eqnarray}

D&\geq 0&\cr

\Rightarrow (-r)^2 - 4(r^2)(1-r) &\geq& 0 \cr

\Rightarrow r^2 - 4r^2 + 4r^3 &\geq& 0\cr

\Rightarrow 4r^3 &\geq& 3r^2\cr

\Rightarrow r &\geq& 3/4

\end{eqnarray}

$$

So, $X(r)$ has real values for $r\geq 3/4$.

This means that $X(1)$ and $X(100)$ have real values, but $X(-1)$ does not. $X(0)$ is undefined because the corresponding equation $(1=0)$ has no solutions, it is a contradiction.

Alex also correctly deduced the maximum and minimum values of $X(r)$

The maximum value of $X(r)$ is $X(1) = 1$. The minimum value of $X(r)$ is $X(3) = -1/3$. The graph has an asymptote $r = 0$.

Alex submitted a plot of the associated curve, which shows two distinct branches.

Steve solved this problem in the following way:

### Part 1:

$$X = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}} {2a}$$

$$X = \frac {1 \pm \sqrt{4r - 3}}{2r}$$

$X$ is therefore real for all $r$ greater than or equal to $\frac{3}{4}$

Hence $r = 0$ and $-1$ give complex roots of $X$ but $1$ and $100$ give real roots.

### Part 2:

Asymptote at $r = 0$

As $r \to \infty$, $X \to 0$

### Part 3:

$$\frac{\mathrm{d}X}{\mathrm{d}r} = \frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}r} \left[ \frac{1}{2r} \left(1 \pm \sqrt{4r - 3} \right) \right] = \frac{- \sqrt{4r-3} \pm(3-2r)} {2r^2 \sqrt{4r-3}}$$

Setting $\displaystyle \frac{\mathrm{d}X}{\mathrm{d}r} = 0$ we find $r = 1,\ 3$

**Editor's Note: The Maximum value of $X(r)$ occurs when $r=1$ and we take the upper branch of the curve (corresponding to the positive square root taken in the quadratic formula). The minimum value of $X(r)$ occurs when $r=3$ in the lower branch.**

**This gives $X_{max}=1$ and $X_{min}=-\frac 13$.**