Coordinate challenge
Use the clues about the symmetrical properties of these letters to place them on the grid.
Problem
Here is a grid:
Can you position these ten letters in their correct places according to the eight clues below?
Clues:
Getting Started
Student Solutions
We had lots of solutions to this problem but not many of you told us how you got your solutions. Luis and Freddie, who go to Newton Prep, sent in well-explained solutions. Here is what Luis wrote:
The first thing I worked out is that the letter at (4,2) is not symmetrical in any way, the only letter that isn't symmetrical in any way is the letter P.
Then I worked out that at (0,2) and (1,2) are the ends of the alphabet and had to be A and Z but I needed to know which one went where so I looked at the clues. One said that (0,2) and (2,0) have rotational symmetry which means that A is on (1,2) and Z is on (0,2).
Then I saw the clue that said that (3,3), (3,2) and (3,1) are all consecutive in the alphabet, because the A and the Z are already used, it has to be C, D and E because it says that (3,3) is made of only curved lines.
Then I saw that one of the clues said that (2,0) is only made of curved lines, so (2,0) is the S.
(4,2) is not symmetrical in any way so (4,2) is a P.
The first clue says that (1,1) and (1,3) have a vertical line of symmetry, another clue says that (1,1) also has a vertical line of symmetry, which means that (1,1) is a X and (1,3) is a Y, which leaves the B which is at (2,1) because a clue says that at (2,1) there is a letter with a horizontal line of symmetry.
Many children from Stradbroke Primary School sent an image of their solution. Here is George's:
Well done!
Rose and Thomas from Minterne Junior School wrote the following
We know that (1,1) = X because it has both horizontal and vertical symmetry.
A had to be (1,2) becuase it has vertical symmetry and is at one end of the alphabet.
Y was placed at (1,3) because it has vertical symmetry.
We knew that X, S and Z have rotational symmetry, but X has to be at (1,1), so Z was placed at (0,2) because it is also at the other end of the alphabet, and S at (2,0) becuase it has
curved lines.
We put C (3,3), D (3,2) and E at (3,1) because they are consecutive.
This works because C at (3,3) also had to consist of curved lines, and E (3,1) had
to have just straight lines.
Finally, we put B on (2,1) becuase it has horizontal symmetry, and P at (4,2) becuase it has no lines of symmetry.
We had the following solution come in from Writtle Junior School in Essex. Reggie, Esther and Emily want to share this:-
I first worked out that [0,2] and [1,2] are A and Z but I needed to work what goes where , I saw [1,2] had vertical symmetry so [1,2] is A so [0,2] is Z. P is not symmetrical in any way so [4,2] is P, S is the only one left with rotational symmetry and Z has taken [0,2] so S is [2,0]. [1,1] is symmetrical horizontally and vertically and X is both so [1,1] is X. Y is left with [1,3] because it is symmetrical vertically and none else are left symmetrical vertically so Y is [1,3]. E Is left with straight lines so E is [3,1]. E is at [3,1] and [3,1], [3,2] and [3,3] are consecutive in the alphabet so [3,2] is D and [3,3] is C. [2,1] is left and B is left [also horizontal like the clue] must be at [2,1].
Well done,all of you for giving such clear descriptions as to how you came to your answer.
Teachers' Resources
Coordinate Challenge
Here is a grid:
Can you position these ten letters in their correct places according to the eight clues below?
Clues:
Why do this problem?
There are two main parts to this problem. Firstly, learners need to identify the symmetries of various capital letters. Secondly, they need to practise reading coordinates. The problem should be approached systematically because some of the clues are not straightforward.
Possible approach
After this learners could work in pairs on the problem so that they are able to talk through their ideas with a partner. They could use this sheet which has letters that can be cut out and moved around. Alternatively, the problem could be tackled on squared paper and the letters drawn on in pencil so that they can be altered easily.
Key questions
What kind of symmetry does this letter have?
Where could this letter go on the grid? How do you know?
Which letters fit this clue?
Possible extension
Learners could explore and list the symmetries of all the other letters of the alphabet.
Possible support
Children could start by identifying the symmetries of the letters, listing whether they have vertical or horizontal line symmetry, rotational symmetry or no symmetry at all. They can then refer to their list as they try to place letters on the grid.