Comparing continued fractions
Which of these continued fractions is bigger and why?
Problem
Suppose $0 < a < b$. Which of the following continued fractions is bigger and why?
\[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{a}}} \] or \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{b}}} \]
Suppose the fractions are continued in the same way, then which is the bigger in the following pair and why?
\[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{4+\frac{1}{a}}}} \]
or the same thing with b in place of a.
Now compare: $${1\over\displaystyle 2 + { 1 \over \displaystyle 3+ { 1\over \displaystyle 4 + \dots + {1\over\displaystyle 99+ {1\over \displaystyle {100 + {1 \over \displaystyle a}} }}}}}$$
and the same thing with $b$ in place of $a$.
Getting Started
Start from the bottom. If you increase the denominator of a fraction do you reduce or increase the value of the fraction?
Student Solutions
Congratulations to Soh Yong Sheng from Raffles Institution,
Singapore for this excellent solution.
We have $0 < a < b$ which means $1/a > 1/b$ and so $3 + 1/a > 3 + 1/b$. Flipping over the fraction, we will get 1/(3 + 1/a) < 1/(3 + 1/b) and the inequality remains the same way round when 2 is added. Flipping over again for the last time we get \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{a}}} \] is greater than \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{b}}} \]
The second part is a further expansion of the first, and in the process of repeating the above we know that it involves just one more flipping over of the fraction, thus \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{4 + \frac{1}{a}}}} \] is less than the same thing with $b$ in place of a as the inequality would be reversed again.
Lastly the continued fractions are expanded all the way down to $100 + 1/a$ and $100 + 1/b$. Observe the above process, we can tell that if the last or biggest number is odd then the continued fraction with a in it is bigger. If the last or biggest number is even then the continued fraction with $b$ in it is bigger. Each successive continued fraction involves one more 'flipping over' and reverses the inequality one more time. The following continued fraction is smaller than the same thing with $b$ in place of $a$: $${1\over\displaystyle 2 + { 1 \over \displaystyle 3+ { 1\over \displaystyle 4 + \dots + {1\over\displaystyle 99+ {1\over \displaystyle {100 + {1 \over \displaystyle a}} }}}}}$$
We have $0 < a < b$ which means $1/a > 1/b$ and so $3 + 1/a > 3 + 1/b$. Flipping over the fraction, we will get 1/(3 + 1/a) < 1/(3 + 1/b) and the inequality remains the same way round when 2 is added. Flipping over again for the last time we get \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{a}}} \] is greater than \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{b}}} \]
The second part is a further expansion of the first, and in the process of repeating the above we know that it involves just one more flipping over of the fraction, thus \[ \frac{1}{2+\frac{1}{3+\frac{1}{4 + \frac{1}{a}}}} \] is less than the same thing with $b$ in place of a as the inequality would be reversed again.
Lastly the continued fractions are expanded all the way down to $100 + 1/a$ and $100 + 1/b$. Observe the above process, we can tell that if the last or biggest number is odd then the continued fraction with a in it is bigger. If the last or biggest number is even then the continued fraction with $b$ in it is bigger. Each successive continued fraction involves one more 'flipping over' and reverses the inequality one more time. The following continued fraction is smaller than the same thing with $b$ in place of $a$: $${1\over\displaystyle 2 + { 1 \over \displaystyle 3+ { 1\over \displaystyle 4 + \dots + {1\over\displaystyle 99+ {1\over \displaystyle {100 + {1 \over \displaystyle a}} }}}}}$$
Teachers' Resources
Why do this problem?
For experience of working with inequalities and with fractions.
Possible approach
If they can't get started students can try numerical values for $a$ and $b$.
Key question
If you increase the denominator of a fraction do you reduce or increase the value of the fraction?
Possible support
Try the problem Not Continued Fractions
Possible extension
See the article Continued Fractions 1