Big, bigger, biggest
Which is the biggest and which the smallest of $2000^{2002}, 2001^{2001} \text{and } 2002^{2000}$?
Problem
Which is the biggest and which the smallest of these numbers?
$$2000^{2002} \quad\quad 2001^{2001}\quad\quad 2002^{2000} $$
How do they compare in magnitude?
Student Solutions
Which is the biggest and which the smallest of these numbers and how do they compare in magnitude?
$$A = 2000^{2002},\ B = 2001^{2001},\ C = 2002^{2000}$$
This solution comes from Ilham, St. Patrick's College, Wellington, well done and thank you Ilham.
First let's define the function floor($x$), where $x$ is a real number, such that floor($x$) = the integer part of $x$.
Let $$y = \rm{floor}(\log_a (x)) + 1$$.
As a general rule, y will be the number of digits of $x$ in base $a$. If we reverse this, we can say that $x$ is somewhere between $a ^ y$ and $a^{y + 1}$.
Another basic rule is $\log_a (b^c) = c\log_a (b)$. If we don't use this rule, the calculation cannot be handled using any standard scientific calculators, as they can't handle calculation with numbers greater than $10^{100}$.
If we use these two rules to $A$, $B$ and $C$ in base $10$, it will show that $A$ has $6609$ digits, $B$ has $6606$ digits, and $C$ has $6603$ digits in base 10.
Therefore, $A$ is bigger than $B$ which in turn is bigger than $C$. $A$ is the biggest, and $C$ is the smallest.
A similar solution uses the fact that the logarithm function is an increasing function so it follows that $$\log A > \log B$$ if and only if $A > B$. Hence
$$\log A = 2002 \log 2000 \approx 2002(3.010) \approx 6608.662$$ $$\log B = 2001 \log 2001 \approx 6605.795$$ $$\log C = 2000 \log 2002 \approx 6602.928$$
The approximate difference is given by : $\log A - \log B = \log A/B \approx 3$, hence $A\approx 10^3B$. Similarly $B\approx 10^3C$. Thus $A > B > C.$
Here is Koopa Koo's more general result.
Claim: $A > B > C$
Proof: $A > B$ if and only if $\log A > \log B.$
I shall prove $\log A - \log B > 0$ i.e. $2002\log2000 - 2001\log2001 > 0.$
Let $f(x) = (x + 2)\log x - (x+1)\log(x+1)$ so that for example f(2) = 4log2 - 3log3.
Differentiating this function, $$f'(x) = (x + 2)/x + \log x - 1 - \log(x + 1) = 2/x -\log[(x+1)/x].$$
This derivative is positive if and only if $e^{2/x}> (x+1)/x.$
Using $e^y > 1 + y$ for all $y$, let $y = 2/x$.
We have $e^{2/x}> 1 + 2/x = (x + 2)/x > (x + 1)/x$.
So the function f is increasing, in particular, $f(2000) = \log A - \log B > 0$ and it follows that $A > B$.
The proof that $B > C$ is similar.
Teachers' Resources
Why do this problem?
This short problem gives students an opportunity to consider how relative sizes might be compared when their calculators don't give an immediate answer. It would make an excellent starter, warm down or stimulus for discussion.
Possible approach
Give students the question without any further explanation. Do they have a gut instinct? Do they think their calculators will be able to help? Is there anything they could do to the expressions to be able to compare their size? Discuss their suggestions and probe what would be required to justify conclusins rigorously.