Adding All Nine
Make a set of numbers that use all the digits from 1 to 9, once and once only. Add them up. The result is divisible by 9. Add each of the digits in the new number. What is their sum? Now try some other possibilities for yourself!
Problem
Make a set of numbers that use all the digits from $1$ to $9$, once and once only.
For instance, we could choose:
$638, 92, 571$ and $4$
Add them up:
$638 + 92 + 571 + 4 = 1305$
$1305$ is divisible by $9$ (it is $145\times 9$)
(use a calculator to check this if you do not know yet how to divide by $9$)
Add each of the digits in the number $1305$ . What is their sum?
Or, perhaps we could choose:
$921, 4357$ and $68$
Add them up:
$921 + 4357 + 68 = 5346$
$5346$ is divisible by $9$ (it is $594 \times 9$)
Now try some other possibilities for yourself!
I wonder what happens if we use all $10$ digits from $0$ to $9$, once and once only?
Try some for yourself!
What do you think would happen if we used the eight digits from $1$ to $8$?
Test your hypothesis by trying some possibilities for yourself!
Were you correct?
Is there a pattern beginning to emerge? Do you have theory that might explain what is happening?
Try some different sets of digits for yourself!
Getting Started
Remember to check your adding.
See how many $2$-digit numbers you can find that are divisible by $9$.
What happens if you just use the numbers from $1$ to $8$?
Student Solutions
Ege, Burcu, Bana and Alara all sent in examples of numbers that they had experimented with. They found that their digits always added up to a multiple of nine, and that the numbers themselves were also divisible by nine. They concluded that there is a link between these two properties, so that if a number has digits that sum up to nine, it must be a multiple of nine. Here are some of their examples:
From the set of numbers from $1$ to $9$ and by using each number once and once only;
Example 1 : $345 + 6789 + 210 = 7344$ =816*9
$7 + 3 + 4 + 4 = 18$. $18$ is a multiple of $9$, so the sum is divisible by nine.
Example 2 : $1023 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9 = 1062$ = 118*9
$1 + 0 + 6 + 2 = 9$. $9$ is a multiple of $9$, so the sum is divisible by nine.
Example 3: $1234 + 56 + 789 = 2079$ = 231*9
$2 + 0 + 7 + 9 = 18$. $18$ is a multiple of $9$, so the sum is divisible by nine.
Example 4: $6723 + 14589 = 21312$ = 2368*9
$2 + 1 + 3 + 1 + 2 = 9$. $9$ is a multiple of $9$, so the sum is divisible by nine.
They also repeated the exercise for the set of numbers $1-8$ and found that the result was the same:
Example 2: $123 + 45 + 67 + 8 = 243$ = 27*9
Example 3: $6245 + 137 + 8 = 6390$ = 710*9
Example 4: $154 + 786 + 32 = 972$ = 108*9
And for the set of numbers $0-9$:
Example 1 : $1023 + 45 + 67 + 89 = 5679$ = 631*9
$5 + 6 + 7 + 9 = 27$. $27$ is a multiple of $9$, so the sum is divisible by nine.
Rohaan from Longbay Primary School explained why this always works for the sum of any numbers made from the digits $1-9$:
I think the reason behind this is when you add all the digits (from $1$ to $9$) the total is $45$. $45$ is divisible $9$ so whatever groups of numbers you make and add up must be divisible by $9$.
That's right, and the numbers $1-8$ add up to $36$, which is also a multiple of $9$, so the rule still works. For the sets of numbers $1-6$ and $1-5$, Ege and Banu found a similarly interesting result for multiples of $3$:
Example 1 : $231 + 4 + 65 = 300$ = 100*3
$3 + 0 + 0 = 3$. $3$ is a multiple of $3$, so the sum is divisible by three.
Example 2 : $12 + 34 + 56 = 102$ = 34*3
$1 + 0 + 2 = 3$. $3$ is a multiple of $3$, so the sum is divisible by three.
So there you have it! This rule only works for multiples of $3$ or $9$, but it makes it very quick and easy to find out whether or not a big number is divisible by $3$ or $9$ without using a calculator. Thank you for all your excellent solutions.
Teachers' Resources
Why do this problem?
Key questions
Possible extension
More able learners could explore what multiples of $9$ they can and cannot make using all the digits $1$ to $9$ once and once only. These will be between $45$ (the result of adding all nine digits as $1$-figure numbers) and $987654321 + 1$. Repeat with he set of numbers $1$ to $8$.
Possible support
Suggest finding different $2$-digit numbers the set of digits $1$ to $9$, and then total these adding in the 'extra' digit and work from this total.