You may also like

problem icon

Always Two

Find all the triples of numbers a, b, c such that each one of them plus the product of the other two is always 2.

problem icon

Not Continued Fractions

Which rational numbers cannot be written in the form x + 1/(y + 1/z) where x, y and z are integers?

problem icon

Coffee

To make 11 kilograms of this blend of coffee costs £15 per kilogram. The blend uses more Brazilian, Kenyan and Mocha coffee... How many kilograms of each type of coffee are used?

Nested Square Roots

Age 14 to 16 Short Challenge Level:

Answer: 3


Squaring both sides
Let $x=\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{...}}}}}$

$\begin{align}x^2&=\left(\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{...}}}}}\right)^2\\
&=3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{...}}}}\\
&=3+2x\end{align}$

So $x^2-2x-3=0\Rightarrow (x-3)(x+1)=0$, so $x=3$ or $x=-1$.

$x$ positive since so $x=3$.

Check: $\sqrt{3+2\times(3)}=3$


'Working it out' using a sequence
Let $x=\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{...}}}}}$

We can approximate $x$ by imagining that we are going to find that large square root as a calculation.

We can start by finding $\sqrt{3}$, and then double it, add $3$, and find the square root of that, and so on.

So if we let $a=\sqrt{3}$, and then $b=\sqrt{3+2\times a}=\sqrt{3+2\sqrt{3}}$, then $c=\sqrt{3+2\times b}=\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3}}}$, and $d=\sqrt{3+2\times c}=\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3+2\times\sqrt{3}}}}$, then the sequence $a, b, c, d, ...$ will get closer and closer to $x$.

Using a calculator, or a spreadsheet, $a=1.73205$, $b=2.54246$, $c=2.84340$, $d=2.94734$, $e=2.98239$, $f=2.99413$, ...

It looks like they are getting closer and closer to $3$, so it looks like $x=3$. If we got to $3$ in our sequence, then the next number in the sequence would be $\sqrt{3+2\times 3}$, which is $\sqrt{3+6}=\sqrt{9}=3$. So if the sequence ever gets to $3$, it will stay at $3$ forever, which strongly suggests that $x=3$.


You can find more short problems, arranged by curriculum topic, in our short problems collection.