List

Probability and Evidence



This collection of resources was developed in collaboration with Professor Philip Dawid of the University of Cambridge



The problems in this collection are about thinking about which questions to ask, and how to interpret the answers.

For example, almost everyone who gets measles gets spots. If you go to your doctor with spots, they won't conclude that you're very likely to have measles, as there are many other diseases that can cause spots.

You need to be careful about the difference between the probability of getting spots if you have measles and the probability of having measles if you get spots. This mistake has caused numerous misunderstandings in medicine, law and wider society.
Introductory Video
page

Introductory Video

An introductory video to the Probability and Evidence collection
Spots and Measles
problem

Spots and measles

Age
11 to 16
Challenge level
filled star filled star empty star
99% of people who have measles have spots. Ben has spots. Do you think he has measles?
Evidence and Headlines
article

Evidence and headlines

Headlines sometimes distort the truth. Read about how micromorts can be used to compare the risks of different activities.
Probability in Court
problem

Probability in court

Age
14 to 18
Challenge level
filled star filled star empty star
When you're on trial for murder, it can be crucial that the court understands probability...
Do Rare Events Happen?
problem

Do rare events happen?

Age
11 to 16
Challenge level
filled star filled star empty star
I'd be very surprised if I had three children all with the same birthday, but I read in the paper that it happened to one family...
Matching Criminals
problem

Matching criminals

Age
14 to 18
Challenge level
filled star filled star filled star
DNA profiling is an invaluable tool for the police. However, when it comes to probability, things aren't always as straightforward as they seem.
The ELISA Test
problem

The ELISA test

Age
14 to 18
Challenge level
filled star filled star empty star

In 1% of cases, an HIV test gives a positive result for someone who is HIV negative. How likely is it that someone who tests positive has HIV?



These resources were originally developed by the Millennium Mathematics Project Motivate Programme in collaboration with Professor Philip Dawid, funded by a Wellcome Trust grant.