Age
7 to 16
| Article by
Chris Budd
| Published

Dancing with Maths



What have the following got in common?
  • A snowflake
  • A starfish
  • A butterfly

They all have symmetry.

Symmetry is the basis of all patterns in art, music, bell ringing, knitting, dancing, crystals, elementary particles and nature.

Reflection Rotation Translation
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths

Something is said to be symmetric if it is not changed by one or more of these operations (reflection, rotation or translation).

Lots of art is based on symmetry, here is a very old example:

Image
Dancing with Maths


Perhaps you can look for pictures that make use of symmetry.


Squares

A square is symmetric. How many symmetries does it have?

A square will look the same under any combination of these symmetries but if we label the corners of the square and apply rotations and reflections we end up with "different" squares. Here are four examples (I have named them 'a', 'b', 'c' and 'd'.

Rotation
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths

a

Reflection
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths

b

Reflection
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths

c

Reflection
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths

Image
Dancing with Maths

d

The simplest symmetry we can have is the"do nothing "symmetry which we shall call 'e'.

Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
We call this symmetry

e

We can combine these symmetries to get new ones.

So, for example:

a

A rotation of 90 degrees

aa

A rotation of 180 degrees

aaa

A rotation of 270 degrees

aaaa

A rotation of 360 degrees = e



You can also combine reflections with themselves:

bb

= ?

cc

= ?

dd

= ?

Answers are at the end of this article.

We have looked at combining rotations and combining reflections but what happens if we combine a rotation with a reflection? Let's look.

Reflection and rotation: ba = ?

Image
Dancing with Maths

Reflection and rotation ba = ?

So - how about ab?

Image
Dancing with Maths

And how about two reflections? bc = ?

Image
Dancing with Maths

Answers are at the end of the article.

Here are some other combinations you might like to check for yourself:

cb = aaa

db = abb = ae = a

By now you might be asking yourself:

"What has all this got to do with dancing?".

Well let me explain...

My name is Chris and fortunately I have three friends called Andrew, Bryony and Daphne (that makes A, B, C and D) who all like dancing.

Image
Dancing with Maths

We make ABCD - four corners of a square. You might already be seeing the connection! If not, here's a hint:

Image
Dancing with Maths

Key Fact: the symmetries of the square correspond to different dance moves.

Reflection
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
b

Dance move

ABCD
Image
Dancing with Maths
ACBD

This dance move is called an "inner-twiddle " or "dos-e-dos "

Reflection
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
Image
Dancing with Maths
c
Dance move


ABCD
Image
Dancing with Maths
BADC

This dance move is called an "outer-twiddle " or "Swing "

Now for the clever bit:

bc =a

Did you remember this?
Therefore

bc b c bc bc = aaaa = e

And this coresponds to a dance called a "Reel of Fou r " or a "Hey ".

Let's do the dance

ABCD
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
ACBD
c
Image
Dancing with Maths
CADB
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
CDAB
c
Image
Dancing with Maths
DCBA
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
DBCA
c
Image
Dancing with Maths
BDAC
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
BADC
c
Image
Dancing with Maths
ABCD

Now find three friends and try it!

Another dance

ABCD
Image
Dancing with Maths
CDAB

d b = a

Therefore

d b d b d b d b = aaaa = e

ABCD
d
Image
Dancing with Maths
CDAB
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
CADB
d
Image
Dancing with Maths
DBCA
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
DCBA
d
Image
Dancing with Maths
BADC
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
BDAC
d
Image
Dancing with Maths
ACBD
b
Image
Dancing with Maths
ABCD

We see the same patterms in bell ringing and in knitting.

Why not see whether you can find other places?

Mathematicians call the study of symmetries Group Theory. The symmetries of the square are an example of a group with 8 members. Some groups are much bigger, for example the monster group has 808017424794512875886459904961710757005754368000000000 members.


It would take a long time to dance that!

Answers

A square has 8 symmetries; 4 rotation symmetries and 4 reflection symmetries

bb, cc and dd all equal e.

ba = c

ab = d

bc = a