Josh and Leyla from St Anthony's School sent in their thoughts:
It is better to use a bar chart because it is easier to see and describe what is going on in the problem.
It is also very quick to see who has the most of something or the least of something.
This would be the easiest that I found to solve this type of problem.
Rahini at Emirates International School Meadows in Dubai wrote:
- I think the first representative was better because it was more organized and easy to count and find the people
- In question 2 I think that the last one is the best.
- All of them do show the exact information but the way they show it is different.
- The second one makes me think that there are more than 100 people.
- All of them make me think that there are loads of people from Asia.
- The easiest to count was the last one.
- Yes, I did realize how a flag had been used because it was linked to the topic.
Tiffany from Mitchell Elementry School in California wrote:
My submission is if the town has happy and unhappy people there are 79 people that are happy and 21 people that are not happy.
Vincent and Salambô at Lycée Henri Matisse in France sent the following:
For the first question about the population of the village, we chose the drawing with the heads organised in a square rather than the drawing with the head scrambled. Because in a square of side $10$ we understand easily that the area is $100$. Thus to symbolise $100$ people the best is to draw a square of side $10$ little heads.
Ben from St. Martin's Gully School, Australia wrote:
In the first graph with the people, I think the first one is best because its meaning is easiest to decipher. In the one with flags, I think the second graph is clearest because it is not as messy as the first one.
We had a response from Amatuliah at Alameen Private School in Dubai who wrote that for question 1 the first way was best and for question 2, the third one was best.
Jenson from Middleton Tyas Church of England Primary School sent in a Word Document which shows his work very clearly - well done! You can view it here or here as a pdf.
Marcus from Peak School in Hong Kong wrote:
We can show the data with tally marks, bar charts and words.
I don’t think pictograms are always the same. I think words are better because maybe the person who is looking at it might not know what the pictogram means unless there is a key for the pictures’ representations.
Pictograms are good to a certain extent if there are keys showing differences of the data and if there are organised systematically.
Fiene, part of the Homeschooling Science Club in the Netherlands, sent in the following:
Our homeschooling Science Club of nine children worked in groups to make posters for:
1. how many people in the village have a telephone
2. how many people in the village have electricity
3. how many people in the village have clean water at home or nearby
What do you think?