Ideal Gases
Age 16 to 18
Challenge Level
This problem is particularly open ended in that it can be tackled
with varying methods. It should be noted that the techniques
illustrated below are only a single way of arriving at sensible
solutions:
0. To calculate the amount of oxygen in the box, it is necessary to
apply the ideal gas equation:
$pV = nRT$
$n = \frac{pV}{RT}$
Useful data to look up is that the standard pressure (according to
IUPAC) is 100kPa, and the standard temperature is 273.15K.
Additionally, R is the gas constant 8.3145
JK$^{-1}$mol$^{-1}$.
Therefore: $n = \frac{10^5 \times 1}{8.31\times 273} = 44
moles$
1. The number of molecules in the box is given by the product of
the number of moles with Avogadro's number:
$N = 44.04 \times 6.022 \times 10^{23} = 2.65 \times 10^{25}$
molecules
Thus, the volume per molecules is: $\frac{1}{N} = 3.77 \times
10^{-26}$ m$^3$.
Assuming an even distribution of molecules, we can model the
situation as each molecule occupying a cube of volume.
The length of each side of the cube is $\sqrt[3]{3.77 \times
10^{-26}} =3.35nm$
Thus, if each molecule is at the centre of its cube of volume, then
the distance between molecules is the same as the length of the
cube.
2. The average speed of molecules in the box can be roughly
estimated as the speed of sound $\approx 330 ms^-1$. A more
rigorous approach is to use an equation from the kinetic gas
theory, which states that:
$\text{Kinetic Energy} = \frac{1}{2}mv^2 = \frac{3}{2}kT$
The mass of a molecule of oxygen can be calculated from knowing
that it's molecular mass is 36 g/mol.
$\therefore \sqrt{ \frac{3kT}{m}} = \sqrt{\frac{3 \times 1.38
\times 10^{-23} \times {273}}{\frac{36 \times 10^{-3}}{6.022\times
10^{23}}}} = 435 ms^{-1}$
3.The time taken to cross the box can be calculated by the width of
the box divided by the speed of the particle:
$t = \frac{1}{435} = 2.30 ms$
4. This is a particularly difficult question to model accurately,
and so we will adopt a particularly easy model. We will assume that
all the particles other than the one under investigation are
stationary. We have calculated that the distance between particles
is 3.35nm, and we can calculate the number of 'particle cubes' that
the moving particle must move through when passing from one side of
the box to the other:
$\text{Number to pass through} = \frac{1}{3.35 \times 10^{-9}} =
2.99 \times 10^{10}$
Thus, the moving particle must move through ~ 3 x 10$^{10}$
particle cubes when traversing the box. However, when passing
through each particle cube, there is only a small probability of
actually colliding with the resident particle. Modelling the oxygen
molecule as a cube of side 100pm, a simple calculation shows that
~38000 of molecules could fit inside each particle cube. Thus, the
probability of this resident particle being in a position where it
will collide with the moving particle is somewhat more than
$\frac{1}{38000}$.
Since the moving particle must pass through 3 x 10$^{10}$ of these
cubes, each with a probability of somewhat more than
$\frac{1}{38000} of causing a collision, it can be seen that we
clearly do not expect the particle to fully traverse the box
without suffering a collision.
5. If the box is oriented such that two of its axes are parallel to
the ground, and one is perpendicular, the following will be
observed: for particles travelling along the two parallel axes,
gravity will have no effect on their time of flight, since
horizontal and vertical motion can be considered independent. For
particles travelling along the third axis, gravity will have the
biggest effect: without gravity, the time taken for them to cross
the box is 2.29864ms, and the time taken for them to travel with
gravity (after a quick calculation) is 2.29859 ms and against
gravity is 2.29870ms. Thus the effect of gravity is small enough
that it can be neglected.
However although these effects are small, they are nonetheless
present. The presence of gravity would mean that there would be a
pressure gradient, as there would be a greater accumulation of
particles towards the bottom of the container, as opposed to the
top. The volume of the box would be unchanged, since the volume is
fixed.
WOULD T CHANGE?
6. What other
assumptions....?
7. One would expect the ideal gas equation to break down once the
volume became sufficiently small that the particles became close to
touching. At this point, the pressure would increase sharply for a
given decrease in volume, since the electron densities would be
repelling each other.To roughly estimate the volume at which this
would be significant, we can calculate the volume of all the
molecules in the box.
We modelled each particle previously as a cube of side 100pm. Given
that there are $2.65 \times 10^{25}$ molecules in the box, the
volume occupied in total is $2.65 \times 10^{-5} m^3 = 26.5cm^3$.
Thus, at this volume, the gas will be exceptionally difficult to
compress. However, it is more than likely that there will be a
deviation from the ideal gas equation at much larger volumes than
this.
8. Without a detailed treatment using the Maxwell-Boltzmann
velocity distribution, this solution can at best be a broad
estimate. We can model the scenario by assuming that all the
particles in the box are moving head-on towards one of the six
walls of the container. Therefore, when one of the walls is
removed, a maximum of 1/6 of the particles could escape. However,
because the wall is removed for only a brief time, only particles
in a certain volume of the container near to the wall can possibly
escape. This volume can be estimated by multiplying the average
molecular speed by the time that the wall is removed for and also
by the cross-sectional area of the box.
Thus, the number of moles of gas that escape are calculated by the
fraction of the volume of the box which gas can escape from,
multiplied by 1/6 and also by the total number of moles of
gas.
Thus, the number escaping:
$\text{Number escaping} = \frac{n}{6} \times \frac{v_{av} \times
time \times area}{volume} = \frac{44.04}{6} \times \frac{435 \times
10^{-9}}{1} = 3.2 \times 10^{-6} moles$
The number of moles of gas in the container has dropped and so the
pressure will reduce too. The temperature will remain constant, as
no work has been done.