How Does Your Function Grow?
Age 16 to 18
Challenge Level
Four enthusiastic mathematicians are asked to think of a function
involving the number 100. The challenge is to think of the function
which is biggest for big values of n
- Archimedes chooses a logarithm function $$A(n) =
\log(100n)$$
- Bernoulli decides to take 100th powers $$B(n) = n^{100}$$
- Copernicus takes powers of 100 $$C(n) = 100^n$$
- and, finally, de Moivre, who likes to be different, chooses the
factorial function which he claims will be quite big enough without
any reference to 100 at all $$D(n) = n\times (n-1)\times
(n-2)\times \dots \times 2\times 1$$
Which function is biggest for large values of n? Can you determine
a value beyond which you know this function will be biggest?
[Extension: To find
the exact switch-over value will be difficult and will require the
clever use of a spreadsheet or computer.]
What could you say if the 100s were replaced by a million?
billions? Create a convincing argument to prove your results to the
mathematicians.