You may also like

problem icon

Consecutive Numbers

An investigation involving adding and subtracting sets of consecutive numbers. Lots to find out, lots to explore.

problem icon

Calendar Capers

Choose any three by three square of dates on a calendar page...

problem icon

Days and Dates

Investigate how you can work out what day of the week your birthday will be on next year, and the year after...

The Simple Life

Age 11 to 14 Challenge Level:

Lily from Jersey College for Girls found another possibility:
I found one possibilty for this question, and my answer became $3(x+2y) + 2(x+y)$, this would lead to $3x+6y + 2x+2y$, then the answer becoming $5x + 8y$.

Minjoon from Seoul Foreign British School found another one:

(so $a=6$ and $b=-1$)

Brian found a possibility using Alison's algebraic method:
$$a(x+2y)+b(2x+3y)=5x+8y\\\Rightarrow\begin{cases}ax+2bx=5x \\2ay+3by=8y\end{cases}\\
\Rightarrow\begin{cases} a+2b=5\\2a+3b=8\end{cases}\\
\Rightarrow a=1\hspace{4mm}\text{and}\hspace{4mm}b=2$$

Rishika from Nonsuch High School for Girls used her own algebraic method, similar to Alison's, to find all of the possibilities:
I used an algebraic method to find the multiples using the following method:
For example, $$a(x+y)+b(x+2y) = 5x+8y$$
{$a$ and $b$ represent the values of the multiples we need to find}

We can then form two equations if we substitute $x=0$ and $y=0$,
When $x=0$,
$$ay+2by = 8y$$
When $y=0$,
$$ax+bx = 5x$$
Then, we can cancel the like terms in each equation:

Equation 1: $a+2b = 8$

Equation 2: $a+b = 5$

Which we can solve simultaneously:

Equation 1 - Equation 2 (as '$a$' is present in both): $b = 3$

Substitute into Equation 2: $a = 2$
Therefore, $2 (x+y) +3 (x+2y) = 5x+8y$

I repeated this for all other possibilities.
Rishika made some mistakes, but these are the ones that Rishika found correctly:
$$\begin{align}2 (x+y) &+3 (x+2y) \hspace{4mm}\text{{from above}}\\
6 (x+y) &-1 (x-2y)\\
4 (x+y) &+1 (x+4y)\\
1 (x+2y) &+2 (2x+3y)\\

Rishika identified all of the possible pairs of expressions. Can you use Rikisha's method, or any other method, to find multiples of these pairs that add up to $5x+8y$?
$(x+y)$ and $(2x+3y)$
$ (x+2y)$ and $(x-2y)$
$ (x+2y)$ and $(x+4y)$
$ (x-2y)$ and $ (x+4y)$
$(x-2y) $ and $ (2x+3y)$
$(x+4y)$ and $ (2x+3y)$