You may also like

problem icon

Counting Counters

Take a counter and surround it by a ring of other counters that MUST touch two others. How many are needed?

problem icon

Cuisenaire Rods

These squares have been made from Cuisenaire rods. Can you describe the pattern? What would the next square look like?

problem icon

Doplication

We can arrange dots in a similar way to the 5 on a dice and they usually sit quite well into a rectangular shape. How many altogether in this 3 by 5? What happens for other sizes?

Fault-free Rectangles

Age 7 to 11 Challenge Level:

Sammy and George from Ardingly, and Bilge, age 12 all sent in correct answers to the first part of the question.

As George explains:

A rectangle doesn't necessarily have to be a oblong it can be a square. All you have to do is build a fault free square which is easy:
You have to put the white square in the middle and then place the red oblongs (so that there are no faults) around the edge of it.

The fault-free rectangle looks like this:


4 red, 1 white

Congratulations to V. Abhijit, age 15 who sent in a fuller solution:

The key behind making a fault free rectangle is this:
Start with a 1 by 1 rectangle, place it at the centre
Now, place 4 2 by 1 rectangles around the 1 by 1 rectangle This will form a fault free rectangle(actually a square, but nevertheless its a rectangle!!)
Thus if you start with a 2 by 1 rectangle, place 2 of them at the centre and then place 4 3 by 1 rectangles around the initial arrangement.

This rectangle is the one made by the red and green rods:
red and green rods

V. Abhijit goes on to generalise...

I noticed that you get a fault free rectangle when I used an "N by 1" rectangle along with an "N+1 by 1" rectangle. I had to put N "N by 1" rectangles at the centre (that forms a square) and then had to place 4 "N+1 by 1" rectangles around the arrangement to get a fault free rectangle(that turned out to be a square)
 

V. Abhijit gives the smallest fault-free rectangle that can be made using 2 by 1 rectangles as that shown below:

 
 
smallest fault-free rectangle
 

Can you find another?