Pythagoras Proofs

Stage: 4 Challenge Level: Challenge Level:2 Challenge Level:2

Here are three different ideas which can lead to proofs of Pythagoras' Theorem. Can you make sense of them? Which proof do you find most "convincing"? Which do you find easiest to understand? Which would you find easiest to explain to someone else?

Firstly:
Draw a square and mark a point a fixed distance from each corner. Join from each of these points to the nearest corner on the opposite side as in the left hand drawing. Cut out the pieces marked in blue and rearrange them to make an L shape like the one on the right.


Use your cutouts to prove Pythagoras' Theorem.
This idea is explored in more detail here

Secondly:

This text is usually replaced by the Flash movie.

Rotate a copy of the trapezium about the centre of the longest side of the blue triangle to make a square. What is the area of the square? From this formula for the area of this square derive a formula for the area of the trapezium. Now write down the area of the trapezium as the sum of the areas of the three right angled triangles. Use these results to give a proof of Pythagoras' Theorem explaining each step.
You can find out more about this proof here

Thirdly:

Take any right-angled triangle and label its sides $a,b$ and $c$.


Enlarge it by scale factor $a$ to make the red triangle and by scale factor $b$ to make the blue triangle.
Join the two enlargements together as shown.
Show that the two joined enlargements form an enlargement of the original triangle by scale factor $c$, and use this to prove Pythagoras' Theorem.
You can explore this idea more here


Published September 2009.