Copyright © University of Cambridge. All rights reserved.
'Power Mad!' printed from http://nrich.maths.org/
An excellent solution to this
problem was sent in by Edward from Carre's Grammar School. Edward
took a sophisticated approach and used modular arithmetic - if you
are not familiar with modular arithmetic this
article will help you follow
his reasoning.
Here is an
outline of what he wrote.
(a) $2^1,\ldots,2^{99}$ can never be multiples on ten since any
multiple of ten is divisible by $5$, and of course no power of $2$
is divisible by $5$.
(b) Edward provided two solutions to this part.
Method 1
We use induction. Clearly $2^1+3^1$ is divisible by $5$. Now for
the induction hypothesis, suppose $2^k+3^k$ is divisible by $5$ for
$k$ odd, i.e. $2^k+3^k=5m$ for some integer $m$.
Then $2^{k+2}+3^{k+2}=4\times 2^k+9\times
3^k=4(2^k+3^k)+5(3^k)=4(5m)+5(3^k)=5(4m+3^k)$ and so is divisible
by $5$. This completes the induction step, and we have shown that
$2^k+3^k$ is divisible by $5$ for
any odd $k$.
Method 2
This method uses modular arithmetic. Edward observed the following
rules:
1. If $a\equiv b$ (mod $m$) then $a^n\equiv b^n$ (mod $m$)
2. If $a\equiv b$ (mod $m$) and $c\equiv d$ (mod $m$) then
$a+c\equiv b+d$ (mod $m$)
Now $2\equiv 2$ (mod $5$) and $3\equiv -2$ (mod $5$), so for any
odd $k$, $3^k\equiv (-2)^k\equiv -2^k$ (mod $5$) using rule (1),
and therefore $2^k+3^k\equiv 2^k-2^k\equiv 0$ (mod $5$) by rule
(2). In other words, $5$ divides $2^k+3^k$ for any odd $k$.
Edward solved the remaining parts
using modular arithmetic.
(c) $2^{99}\equiv 0$ (mod $2$), and $1^{99}+3^{99}\equiv 1+1\equiv
0$ (mod $2$) so $1^{99}+2^{99}+3^{99}$ is divisible by $2$.
(d) $2^{99}+3^{99}\equiv 0$ (mod $5$) by part (b). Similarly, since
$4\equiv -1$ (mod $5$), $1^{99}+4^{99}\equiv 1^{99}+(-1)^{99}\equiv
0$ (mod $5$). Therefore $1^{99}+2^{99}+3^{99}+4^{99}$ is divisible
by $5$.
We will leave parts (e)-(h) for
the reader. See if you can use modular arithmetic to prove
them.
We also received a nice solution
from Yike, who concentrated on the last digits of the numbers and
found various patterns. Can you prove that these patterns hold for
all natural numbers? Why not try using modular
arithmetic?