Six times five
Problem
How many six-digit numbers are there which DO NOT contain a $5$?
Getting Started
Student Solutions
Firstly consider the number of six digit numbers - this is 900,000.
$\frac19$ of all six digit numbers start with a 5. So 100,000 six digit numbers are of the form 5******
This leaves 800,000 numbers that do not start with a 5.
$\frac1{10}$ of the remaining numbers have a 5 in the ten-thousands column, so we need to subtract 80,000 from 800,000 leaving 720,000.
$\frac1{10}$ of the remaining numbers have a 5 in the thousands column, so we need to subtract 72,000 from 720,000, leaving 648,000.
$\frac1{10}$ of the remaining numbers have a 5 in the hundreds column, so we need to subtract 64,800 from 648,000, leaving 583,200.
$\frac1{10}$ of the remaining numbers have a 5 in the tens column, so we need to subtract 58,320 from 583,200 leaving 524,880.
$\frac1{10}$ of the remaining numbers have a 5 in the units column, so we need to subtract 52,488 from 524,880, leaving 472,392.
A slightly quicker method would be to multiply by 0.9 instead of subtracting $\frac1{10}$ in each of the above steps.
Here is a different solution, from Junwei of BHASVIC
Let the six digits number is abcdef, which a, b, c, d ,e, f represent a digit respectively.
For a, neither 0 nor 5 could place in it, thus, 8 digits are available here (1,2,3,4,6,7,8,9)
For b, c, d, e and f, they can't contain 5, hence, 9 digits are available for them (0,1,2,3,4,6,7,8,9)
Therefore, the no. of six digits number which does not contain any 5 is
8 * 9 * 9 * 9 * 9 *9 =472392 .
Teachers' Resources
Why do this problem?
This problem is short and encourages students to think about the meaning of place value and engages their logical thinking. It could be used as a starter to engage pupils as they come in to the classroom, though there are good extensions available for a full lesson.Possible approach
Key questions
- Is $000001$ a six-digit number?
- How many six-digit numbers are there?
- How many choices do we have for the first digit?
- How many choices do we have for the second digit?
Possible extension
- How many six-digit numbers do not contain a $5$ or a $7$?
- How many six-digit numbers are there for which the digits increase from left to right (such as $134689$ or $356789$)?
- How many numbers less than $10$ million do not contain a $5$?
- Will your methods extend to similar problems? if so, can you express them algebraically?
- What other [interesting] questions could you ask starting "How many six-digit numbers..."?
Possible support
- You could ask the almost equivalent question "How many six-figure telephone numbers do not contain a $5$?". This encourages student to imagine dialling a number in sequence, which will may help them to see the different choices which can be made at each step of the process.
- Encourage students to adapt the problem to make it accessible: fewer digits, how many six-digit numbers are a multiple of $10$ (probably seen as a number with $0$ as last digit) or even, or a mult of $5$, or square, etc.