a question on integration Log Out | Topics | Search Moderators | Register | Edit Profile

 Ask NRICH » Archive 2010-2011 » Onwards and Upwards » a question on integration « Previous Next »

Author Message
Kira J
Poster

Post Number: 7
 Posted on Sunday, 01 May, 2011 - 11:19 am:

x=a*exp(bu)cos(u), y=a*exp(bu)sin(u)

wish to integrate [x'(u)*y"(u)-y'(u)x"(u)]/(x'(u)2+y'(u)2) with respect to u. Looks like the form of the integrand has something to do with the quotient rule but I don't know what. I think the question is certainly not intended so that I will have to find out what the derivatives are and the integrate.

Can anyone help?
Daniel Fretwell
Veteran poster

Post Number: 1280
 Posted on Sunday, 01 May, 2011 - 11:55 am:

This looks like something related to (but isnt) curvature.

The denominator would have to be to the power 3/2 for this to be true.

However, if you plod through the workings you will find a nice surprise at the end. Things will simplify nicely.
Simon Taylor
Veteran poster

Post Number: 449
 Posted on Sunday, 01 May, 2011 - 12:13 pm:

There is an outrageous bit of 'look it looks like this', but it is almost impossible to find unless you have seen it before. It isn't using quotient rule. Solving the hard way is tedious but works.
lebesgue
Veteran poster

Post Number: 2143
 Posted on Sunday, 01 May, 2011 - 12:35 pm:

What you want to integrate is a nice function in terms of h(u):=y'(u)/x'(u) and h'(u), can you see that?