Parallel pentagon problem


By Peter Gyarmati on Friday, September 13, 2002 - 02:17 pm:

Given that each side of a convex pentagon is parallel to one of its diagonals. What may be the ratio of the length of a side to that of the parallel diagonal?


By Ngoc Tran on Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 11:29 am:

Here is my proof (you can apply this proof with any side of any pentagon):

Call the pentagon ABCDE. Call the length of CD, k. We have to find the length of the parallel diagonal of CD - which is BE.

Draw the pentagon. AC meet BE at M. Call the length of BM, x. BD meet AC at N, meet CE at H.

Because BM = x we have that BE = x + k
Because BE // CD so:
BM/CD = BN/ND = HD/BH = CD/BE
--> BM.BE = CD2 --> x x (x+k) = k2
which means
BE = CD2 /BM

NOTE: when k is known, we can find the value of x from the formula x x (x+k) = k2 by solving the equation:
k2 + kx - x2 = 0

Ngoc,


By David Loeffler on Wednesday, September 18, 2002 - 02:32 pm:

There is also an approach by linear transformations, which avoids you having to do any real work at all!

Given the trapezoid ABCD (where AD // BC), one can apply a shear parallel to AD and BC which makes it into an isosceles trapezium. Assume AD is longer than BC.

Define K = intersection of line through A parallel to BD and line through D parallel to AC, and define K' = intersection of line thru B par to CD and line thru C par to AB.

Evidently as the angle ABC increases, K will move away from BC and K' will move towards it. Hence there is a unique point at which K = K' (and it is not difficult to see that at this unique point ABCDE is a regular pentagon stretched parallel to BC).

David


By Peter Gyarmati on Wednesday, September 18, 2002 - 02:33 pm:
I calculated the ratio.

x×(x+k)= k2 , let x be the variable. So:

x=k×(5-1)/2 ( x=CD)

BE=k+x=k×(5+1)/2,

CD/BE=k/(k×(5+1)/2

CD/BE=1/(5+1)/2

CD/BE = 0,61803398


I think the ratio is the same in all case: any side/diagonal, in every possible convex pentagon.
It was a deep thought to use the ratios (BM/CD = BN/ND = HD/BH = CD/BE)to get the solution. I didn't see this.

I thank everybody for the help!

Peter