We all know the solution to the general quadratic
ax2 +bx+c=0. Does anyone know about the general
solution to the cubic? I know that Galois theory proves that
certain equations of higher degree have no solution. Does this
apply to all higher degree polynomials? Could you explain the
extreme BASICS of galois theory so that an A'level student could
understand it? Maybe you know of how to reduce the difficulty of
finding the solution to higher degree polynomials ( ie: by
looking for symmetry in the coefficients).
Thanks for any help.
P.S: Can you solve this?:
x6 +x2 +x=0
Thanks!!
For a derivation of the cubic formula see these threads in
Asked NRICH:
Solving Cubic Equations
Quick factorisation of
polynomials
Formula for solving cubic
equations
I can't help with Galois theory I'm afraid... Perhaps someone
else who knows a bit about that can comment.
And I'm afraid I can't solve your equation. Clearly one solution
is x = 0, but then I can't find a neat way of analysing:
x5 + x + 1 = 0
Well, I just tried this equation in
Mathematica, and it has some nasty roots. You can simplify it by
using -(-1)1/3 is a root, as is (-1)2/3 .
Finding the rest of the roots just involves solving a cubic, but
it's algebraically messy, involving cube roots of 25-3 sqrt(69)
and things like that.
I don't know if there is an easy introduction to Galois theory,
having only just done the course in my third year at university.
The basic idea is that you look at "field extensions" of the
rationals. For instance Q[sqrt(2)] is the set of numbers
a+b.sqrt(2) for rational numbers a and b. A "radical extension"
of a field K (a field is basically something where you can add,
subtract, multiply and divide elements, for instance the
rationals, the reals or the complex numbers) is a field
K[x1/n ] where x is an element of K. For instance
Q[sqrt(2)] and Q[fifthroot(-1)] are radical extensions of Q, the
rationals. A more complicated one is Q[sqrt(2)][sqrt(1+sqrt(2))]
which is a radical extension of Q[sqrt(2)] (let K=Q[sqrt(2)],
x=1+sqrt(2) is in K and K[sqrt(x)] is
Q[sqrt(2)][sqrt(1+sqrt(2))]).
You say that a polynomial equation p(x)=0 is soluble by radicals
if there is a series of radical extensions of Q which has the
roots of p(x)=0 in them. For instance x4
+x2 +1=0 is soluble by radicals, because if you let
y=x2 then y2 +y+1=0 which is soluble by
radicals (just use the quadratic formula). But then you can just
take the positive and negative square roots of y to get the
solutions to the original equation.
To prove that there are quintics which aren't soluble by
radicals, you need to introduce the idea of the "Galois group" of
a polynomial, which I won't go into here. You then show that if
an equation is soluble by radicals, then the Galois group of the
polynomial is "soluble" (the definition of this I also won't go
into here). However, you can show that S5 (the
symmetry group on 5 elements) isn't a soluble group, and you can
find a polynomial with Galois group S5 , so this
cannot be soluble by radicals.
I'll recommend Ian Stewart's Galois
Theory again as a relatively unfrightening introduction. See also
this discussion on Radicals for my comments on
Galois Theory. Roughly it's all about symmetries of roots in the
complex plane fixing the rationals.
For example, consider f(X) = X2 - 2. This polynomial
has roots sqrt(2) and -sqrt(2), and splits into factors in
Q[sqrt(2)]. The only symmetry of the roots which fixes Q - the
rational numbers - is sqrt(2) < -> -sqrt(2), so the Galois
group is cyclic of order 2 - it contains the identity symmetry
(leave everything where it was) and the symmetry above, which is
of order two since performing it twice puts everything back as it
was.
Can you see what possible symmetries there are for the
following?
f(X) = X2 - 3 f(X) = X4 - 2
f(X) = X2 - 5X + 6
f(X) = X5 - 1
f(X) = X5 - X - 1
Some of these are really hard...
Hope this helps.
Vivien