Often people who don't know how to add fractions do so as if the rule is
a b + c d = a+c b+d

where a and b are coprime and c and d are coprime. Does this ever give the right answer?

As Andrei Lazanu from Tudor Vianu National College, Bucharest, Romania says "The only solution for the problem is a=-c and b=d so that the sum
a b + c d

is zero and
a+c b+d =0,

so the relation is true".

Why is this the only possibility? The relation


a b + c d = a+c b+d

holds if and only if
ad+bc bd = a+c b+d

that is
(ad+bc)(b+d)=(a+c)bd

which holds if and only if
ad2 + b2 c=0,

or equivalently
ad2 =- b2 c.

We know that any whole number can be written as the unique product of prime factors. As a and b are coprime and c and d are coprime ad2 =- b2 c is true only if a divides c and c divides a and they are of opposite sign, that is a=-c. Thus the original formula holds if and only if d=±b and b+d0 that is b=d so the formula holds if and only if a b = -c d and their sum is zero.