Often people who don't know how to add fractions do so as if the rule
is
where
and
are coprime and
and
are coprime.
Does this ever give the right answer?
As Andrei Lazanu from Tudor Vianu National College, Bucharest,
Romania says "The only solution for the problem is
and
so that the sum
is zero and
so the relation is true".
Why is this the only possibility? The relation
holds if and only if
that is
which holds if and only if
or equivalently
We know that any whole number can be written as the unique product
of prime factors. As
and
are coprime and
and
are
coprime
is true only if
divides
and
divides
and they are of opposite sign, that is
. Thus
the original formula holds if and only if
and
that is
so the formula holds if and only if
and their sum is zero.