Copyright © University of Cambridge. All rights reserved.

'Flippin' Discs' printed from https://nrich.maths.org/

Show menu


Ruby and Emma from Yewdale Primary in the UK estimated the numbers of wins they would get by thinking about winning combinations:
2 discs- out of 1000 we got 490 wins which is 49%- We predicted 45% to 55% as there are 4 possibilities and only 2 of them give you a point.

Mahdi from Mahatma Ghandi International School in India showed the 4 combinations as an image, and calculated a probability:

From the 4 possible outcomes only 2 are valid.

$\text{Probability} = \dfrac{\text{favourable outcomes}}{\text{total number of outcomes}} = \dfrac24 = 0.5 = 50\%$

Atharva from Wilson's School used the same method, and concluded:
So you should win 50% of the time.


This is the rest of Ruby and Emma's answer. They made mistakes finding the numbers of possibilities, but their answer is still correct in principle:
3 discs- out of 1000 we got 311 wins which is 31.1%- We predicted 20% to 30% as there are nine possibilities and again only 2 of them give you a point.

4 discs- out of 1000 we got 134 wins which is 13.4% - we predicted 10% to 20% as there are 16 possibilities and only 2 of them give you a point.

5 discs - out of 1000 we got 54 wins which is 5.4% - we predicted about 4% to 9% as there are 25  possibilities and only 2 give you a point.

The pattern is that whenever the numbers of discs are bigger, the percentage decreases.

We estimated with 6 discs and out of 1000- we predicted about 3% to 4.5% as
there are 36 possibilities and only 2 give you a point.

Sanika P from PSBBMS, OMR in India, Mahdi and Atharva all continued listing the possibilies. This is Sanika's work for 3 discs:
D1 D2 D3
R R R
G G R
R G R
G R R
R R G
G G G
R G G
G R G

Among these, the first and the sixth (2) combinations are considered as wins out of the 8 possible outcomes.

Therefore the probability of winning when there are 3 discs is $\frac28$ or 25%

This is Mahdi's work for 4 discs:
 
From the 16 possible outcomes only 2 are valid.

$\text{Probability} = \dfrac{\text{favourable outcomes}}{\text{total number of outcomes}} = \dfrac2{16} = 0.125 = 12.5\%$


Atharva spotted a pattern:
2 discs = 50%
3 discs = 25%
4 discs = 12.5%
5 discs = 6.25%

Ergo you just half the percentage for the next one, e.g.
6 discs = 3.125%

Can you see how this follows from Mahdi's image? If you ignore the last disc in each image, the possibilities for 3 discs all appear twice - so the number of possibilities doubles each time you add another disc. How is that related to Atharva's pattern?


Ahan from Tanglin Trust School in Singapore, Mahdi and Sanika found the same pattern but described it in a different way. Sanika wrote:

By extending this is $n$ discs
$D_1,D_2,...D_n$     Each of the discs can have $2$ possible states - Red or Green. So the total [number of] possible outcomes [is] $2^n$

Among the possible outcomes only $2$ could be win wherein all the discs are of same colour.
Therefore the probability of winning with $n$ discs  is equal to $\dfrac2 {2^n} = \dfrac{1}{2^{n-1}}$