Copyright © University of Cambridge. All rights reserved.

'Which Solids Can We Make?' printed from http://nrich.maths.org/

Show menu


This problem follows on from Semi-regular Tessellations.
 
Here are pictures of the five Platonic Solids - solids made from just one type of polygon, with the same number of polygons meeting at each vertex.
 
platonic solids

 
Can you convince yourself that there are no more?

The angle deficit at a vertex of a polyhedron is a measure of how far short each angle sum is from $360^{\circ}$.
For example, in a dodecahedron, three pentagons with interior angles of $108^{\circ}$ meet at each vertex, so the angle sum is $324^{\circ}$ and the angle deficit is $36^{\circ}$:
 
 three pentagons meeting
Can you work out the angle deficit at the vertices of the other Platonic solids?    
The total angle deficit is the sum of the deficits at each vertex.
What do you notice about the total angle deficit for the Platonic solids? 

 
Archimedean Solids have two properties:
  • They are formed by two or more types of regular polygons, each with the same side length
  • Each vertex has the same pattern of polygons around it. 

Here is a picture of an Archimedean Solid with 24 vertices. Its vertex form {3, 3, 3, 3, 4} is defined by the polygons that meet at each vertex: triangle, triangle, triangle, triangle, square.
 
solid with vertex form 3,3,3,3,4
Calculate the total angle deficit for this solid. Does it match your observations about the Platonic solids?
 
Try to suggest some other vertex forms which might give rise to Archimedean solids, assuming all solids share the property you have discovered. If you have access to construction sets such as Polydron, you could test out your ideas.

Below are some vertex forms you might like to try: some of them give rise to solids and some of them don't. Can you decide which will work before testing them out? 
 
 suggested vertex forms