You may also like

problem icon

Upsetting Pitagoras

Find the smallest integer solution to the equation 1/x^2 + 1/y^2 = 1/z^2

problem icon

Lunar Leaper

Gravity on the Moon is about 1/6th that on the Earth. A pole-vaulter 2 metres tall can clear a 5 metres pole on the Earth. How high a pole could he clear on the Moon?

problem icon

Seriesly

Prove that k.k! = (k+1)! - k! and sum the series 1.1! + 2.2! + 3.3! +...+n.n!

Odd One Out

Stage: 5 Short Challenge Level: Challenge Level:1

Why do this problem?

This problem helps to develop the skill of working with large sets of numbers and getting a 'feel' for their properties. Being able to spot anomalous data quickly is very useful in industrial and research contexts, and this problem could be considered numerical detective work.

Possible approach

This activity could be used with small groups of students working on computers or with the whole class working together, perhaps with printed copies of a dataset. Give students plenty of time to study the data and discuss in small groups anything they notice.

When they think they have identified an odd one out for most or all of the six processes, students could explain to one another how they think the processes work and how sure they are that they have correctly identified the odd one out. They could then test their identification of the processes with new data.

Key questions

Are there any patterns to the data? Is there anything that doesn't fit with the patterns you see?
Can we ever be sure that our explanation of the processes is correct?
At what point do we accept that our explanation is correct?

Possible extension

There is scope for lots of statistical calculation to justify the decisions students make for the odd ones out, by calculating the probability of those errors arising by chance, and working out how likely it is that the data was generated by processes other than those they have assumed.

Possible support

The problem Data Matching gives an opportunity to look at and compare data sets.