We have yet to receive a solution that uses only Level 4 mathematics, (so a solution that doesn't use logs) and so this problem has become Toughnut! See if you can crack it and send us your solution!

We have now received some excellent solutions for this Toughnut question. Patrick from Woodbridge School solved the first question by making a list of each years values:

Let x be the original value.

To add 10%, we multiply by 1.1, and we are trying to reach 2x. Thus, we get

x

1.1x

1.21x

1.331x

1.4641x

1.61051x

1.771561x

1.9487171x

2.14358881x

So, after 8 years, the sum has doubled.

To reduce a value by 10%, we multiply by 0.9, and we must reach 0.5x. Thus, we get

x

0.9x

0.81x 11

0.729x

0.6561x

0.59049x

0.531441x

0.4782969x

so after 7 years the sum has halved in value.

Alexandra, Shannon, Gemma, Katie, Ruby and Caitlin from Herts and Essex High School for Girls also worked out the problem in this way correctly. Well done!

Iain from St. Gregory's Catholic High and Daniel from King's College, Madrid used logarithms to solve the problem:

If a sum increases by 10% each year this means that the value of the previous year is multiplied by 1.1 (it is 110% of what it was before). Therefore for an initial value "a" the progression will be:

Year: 0 1 2 3 ...

$a$ $a\times1.1$ $(a\times1.1)\times1.1$ $((a\times1.1)\times1.1)\times1.1)$

= $a$ $a\times(1.1)$ $a\times(1.1^2)$ $a\times(1.1^3)$ ...

A sum invested gains 10% each year:

$1.1^n = 2$ (1)

$n log 1.1 = log2$

$n = \frac{log2}{log1.1} = 7.273$ (4.s.f.)

It will therefore be 8 years before the sum is effectively doubled.

An object depreciates in value by 10% each year:

$0.9^m = 0.5$ (2)

$mlog0.9 = log0.5$

$m = \frac{log0.5}{log0.9} = 6.579$ (4.s.f.)

It will therefore be 7 years before the sum is effectively halved.

Patrick from Woodbridge School went on to explain why it takes different time for the value to double and half:

Why aren't these two answers the same?

The answers are not the same as, when 10% is added to a value, less than 10% must be taken off as the 10% of the new number is larger. This can be summed up as:

If $10$%$\times x + x = y$

then $y - 10$%$\times y < x$

Is there a rate, used for both gain and depreciation, for which those two answers would actually be the same?

For the above reason, there is no such rate as this is true for all numbers and all percentages, except 0% and £0.

For a non-zero initial value, we cannot find a non-zero rate for which the time taken for the value to double and half would be the same. This is because for any rate, the ratio of values between two successive years will be different for gain and depreciation. To get the same time we really need these ratios to be the same.

Well done everyone!