You may also like

problem icon

I'm Eight

Find a great variety of ways of asking questions which make 8.

problem icon

Calendar Capers

Choose any three by three square of dates on a calendar page. Circle any number on the top row, put a line through the other numbers that are in the same row and column as your circled number. Repeat this for a number of your choice from the second row. You should now have just one number left on the bottom row, circle it. Find the total for the three numbers circled. Compare this total with the number in the centre of the square. What do you find? Can you explain why this happens?

problem icon

Domino Square

Use the 'double-3 down' dominoes to make a square so that each side has eight dots.

Pair Sums

Stage: 3 Challenge Level: Challenge Level:3 Challenge Level:3 Challenge Level:3
Many people correctly noticed that it won't help to take two of the same number because then there won't be enough different totals. Tyler, Harry and others started with ways of making 0. Having decided that taking 0 + 0 = 0 won't work, they realised that a negative number and its positive value are needed. Hannah started with -1 and 1, then found what else is needed to make the rest of the totals. Using trial and improvement gives something like this:

Can't take 2 because -1 + 2 = 1 is not allowed.
Must take 3 because -1 + 3 = 2 and 1 + 3 = 4 are needed.
Can't take 4 because -1 + 4 = 3 is not allowed
Must take 5 because -1 + 5 = 4, 1 + 5 = 6 and 3 + 5 = 8 are needed.
At this point you need 10 to make 15, and need to check that all the possible totals are reached, and nothing extra.

Well done to everyone who used a method like this to get the right answer! It's lucky that -1 and 1 were in the solution, or else you'd need to try -2 and 2, -3 and 3, ...

Woo from Hampton School gave an algebraic solution; since it's often useful to use letters to represent unknown numbers this sounds like a good idea!

The five numbers can be thought of as a, b, c, d and e with

a < b < c < d < e

Then we can order the totals too. There is a grid of inequalities
\begin{array}{ccccccc}
a+b \\
{}\wedge{}\\
a+c &<& b+c\\
{}\wedge{} && {}\wedge{}\\
a+d &<& b+d &<& c+d\\
{}\wedge{} && {}\wedge{} && {}\wedge{}\\
a+e &<& b+e &<& c+e &<& d+e\\
\end{array}
Therefore, smallest combinations are as follows in order:

a+b < a+c < b+c or a+d < b+d…

And the totals are 0, 2, 4, 4, 6, 8, 9, 11, 13, 15 so

0 = a+b
2 = a+c

both b+c and a+d can be the third or fourth total, but both are 4, hence

4 = b+c
4 = a+d

And treating the first three equations as a system of simultaneous equations, they can be solved to find a. This gives -2 = 2a. So a = -1, b = 1, c = 3 and d = 5. There is one last number to find; e. We know the largest total is 15 = d+e; so must have e = 10.

Well done Woo, this is very sophisticated. Sometimes it's hard to know when trial and improvement won't work so it's useful to have an algebraic method that doesn't rely on trials.