nrich
enriching mathematics
Skip over navigation
Home
Home
Students
Guide and features
Teachers
Guide and features
STEM
Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics
AskNRICH
Forum
early years
Featured Early Years Foundation Stage; US Kindergarten
Early years
primary
Featured UK Key Stage 1&2; US Grades 1-4
Primary teachers
secondary
Featured UK Key Stage 3-5; US Grades 5-12
Secondary teachers
primary lower
Featured UK Key Stage 1, US Grade 1 & 2
primary
primary
Featured UK Key Stage 2; US Grade 3 & 4
secondary lower
Featured UK Key Stages 3 & 4; US Grade 5-10
secondary
secondary upper
Featured UK Key Stage 4 & 5; US Grade 11 & 12
Topics
translate
Problem
Getting Started
Solution
Teachers' Resources
Printable page
You may also like
After Thought
Which is larger cos(sin x) or sin(cos x) ? Does this depend on x ?
Climbing
Stage: 5
Challenge Level:
Thank you Andrei Lazanu from Tudor Vianu National College, Bucharest, Romania for this solution.
To solve the problem, I plotted three functions for $0 \leq x \leq \pi/2$. Below are the graphs of the three functions, all three plotted on the same figure with $y_1={2x\over \pi}$ in blue, $y_2 = \sin x$ in green and $y_3=x$ in red.
As seen from the figure, the green graph (i.e. $y = \sin x$) is situated between the other two graphs in the range of $0 \leq x \leq \pi/2$. For all $x$ between 0 and $\pi/2$ the point $(x, \sin x)$ is above the point $(x, 2x/\pi)$ and hence $${2x\over \pi} \leq \sin x.$$ In this interval the graph of $\sin x$ lies below the line $y=x$ because this line meets the graph of $\sin x$ at the origin and the gradient of $\sin x$ is less than 1 for all $x$. Hence $\sin x \leq x$.
For the second part of the problem, I have to prove that: $${\tan a \over \tan b} < {a \over b}.$$ For any $a$ and $b$ in this interval, both $a$, $b$, $\tan a$ and $\tan b$ are positive, so that the original inequality is equivalent to the following one: $${\tan a \over a} < {\tan b \over b}$$ In the figure below the graph of function $y=\tan x/x$ is plotted for $0 < x < \pi/2$.
I observe that the function is monotonically increasing. This means that for any $a < b$ (but remaining in the interval $0 < a < b < \pi/2$), $y(a) < y(b)$ as required.
Alternatively, from the graph of $y = \tan x$ in this interval, if $a < b$ then the gradient of line joining the origin the point $(a, \tan a)$ is less than the gradient of the line joining the origin to the point $(b, \tan b)$ so $${\tan a \over a} < {\tan b \over b}$$ and hence $${\tan a \over \tan b} < {a \over b}.$$
Circular functions
.
Inequality/inequalities
.
Mathematical reasoning & proof
.
Graphs
.
Gradients
.
Graph plotters
.
Cubic functions
.
Manipulating algebraic expressions/formulae
.
Transformation of functions
.
Graphical calculators
.