You may also like

problem icon

Are You a Smart Shopper?

In my local town there are three supermarkets which each has a special deal on some products. If you bought all your shopping in one shop, where would be the cheapest?

problem icon

Would You Rather?

Would you rather: Have 10% of £5 or 75% of 80p? Be given 60% of 2 pizzas or 26% of 5 pizzas?

problem icon

You Never Get a Six

Charlie thinks that a six comes up less often than the other numbers on the dice. Have a look at the results of the test his class did to see if he was right.

The Magic Number and the Hepta-tree

Stage: 2 Challenge Level: Challenge Level:2 Challenge Level:2

The Magic Number and the Hepta-Tree


The Mathemagician needs to break a dreadful spell! Help him to find the magic number that will do the trick!

Here is the hepta-tree hung with silver balls.

Hepta-Tree. The balls on the hepta-tree say

Do you think the balls will have similar values?

Try estimating the amount on each ball.

In order to break the spell, firstly find the exact difference between the largest ball and the smallest ball.

Multiply your result by $244$.

Round this to a whole number and that gives us the MAGIC NUMBER!

Give this number to the Mathemagician and the terrible spell will be broken for ever!


Why do this problem?

This problem gives work on percentages in an interesting and challenging way. It also gives you an opportunity to discuss different ways of estimating and therefore shows learners how expressions which look very different can give very close answers.

Possible approach

You could start by showing the group the picture of the hepta-tree and invite them to give a quick response as to which ball they think has the highest value and which one the smallest. Ask them to estimate the value of each ball in pairs and encourage several pairs to share their method with everyone. This will bring out the fact that actually the balls have very similar values.

After this they could work in pairs on the problem itself, possibly using this sheet (which lists the expressions on the balls). Learners are likely to need pencil and paper or a mini-whiteboard and pen, and possibly a calculator.

At the end of the lesson encourage the group to discuss the problem. Finding out how each pair approached it could be very useful as learners will gain from seeing what others have done. By sharing calculation strategies, children's understanding of the relationship between percentages, fractions and decimals will be deepened and you will be able to assess how comfortable they are with this area of mathematics.

Key questions

What do you notice when you estimate the value of each ball?
How could you work out the exact value of this ball?
What do you notice about the numbers you have found?
How do you know which is the highest/lowest number?

Possible extension

Learners could create more percentages like the ones on the hepta-tree which look different but have very close answers. These could range like the ones in the problem or approximate to another number. It would be interesting to talk to children about how they were coming up with the percentages.

Possible support

Using this sheet will help children organise their calculations and it may be appropriate for some to use a calculator.